Caps are more than one player away for sure. Well, currently they are two of our own players away; Wilson and PLD, and both with make a huge difference, but not enough.
Willy makes a difference on the ice every game, and every player on both teams knows it. PLD will make a big impact (assuming we get the good PLD back) in that you won't have mediocre inadequate guys playing spots and minutes they aren't worthy of. Sourdiff has been great, but he's not a 2C, neither is McMike or Lappy or Dowd or anyone else we've tried. PLD at 2C and Willy back puts the mediocre guys back in places they should be and fills out our top two lines much better, but even at that, we DO have a team full of mediocre guys and we need a real top line goal scorer.
I like many of these guys, but if you filled my team with a bunch of strangers and they made us a reasonable contender, I'd learn to like them too.
In Rich's Fantasy Land, I'm keeping for next season:
Willy, Ovi, Protus, PLD, Leonard, Sourdiff, Strome, McMike
Chychrun, Roy, Fever
Thompson for sure, fine with Lindy as well
I would entertain a trade for McMike, PLD, even Strome if there were serious active interest. Ovi is basically untradeable, and I think will play one more year which I can tolerate given what he has done for this franchise. He is untradeable, but also limits what we can do with him in the lineup.
I would actively seek a trade for Carlson this year - he could be decent trade bait for a contender; possible help in a SC run, yet no contract to worry over. Same for TVR except I don't see him as an asset to anyone wanting to strengthen their playoff run.
Sandin I would gladly part with as well if someone wanted him for some sort of return.
Frank, Beauvy, Duhaime all work really hard, but wouldn't be heartbroken if they were traded. I'd certainly give Frank a shot next year at a reasonable contract if he's not traded. He's a decent 3rd line guy with some scoring potential. Duhaime is a utility guy with lots of grit, and love him but he has little impact.
Carlson, TVR, Dowd, Milano, Lappy - I don't want to see any of these guys in a Caps sweater next season.
The REALITY is....ALL these scrubs will be back next year except for maybe the few UFA's; Milano, Frank, Duhaime, TVR
Carlson is a UFA but the Caps are going to overpay him for a ridiculous long albatross contract. (Please please prove me wrong)
Frank has played well enough someone will pick him up this summer. Milano might get a job with someone. TVR - I just don't know. He might be good enough for some teams bottom pairing, but I don't want it to be the Caps
McMike and Lappy are RFA's. McMike will certainly get an offer somewhere if we don't keep him, but Lappy - oof, someone will offer him a contract.
The Caps have never been a big trade kind of team. Never seen them really do a rebuild. Probably the biggest moves I can ever really recall are when they went after PLD and Chicky. PLD was better than expected, and we offloaded a bad (for us) goalie at the same time. Chicky was a great acquisition.
I hesitate to recall the Jagr experiment which was a failure, but at least was an effort at a top echelon talent.
With so many teams still in the hunt, I would think it would be a sellers market so let's take advantage of that NOW.
Wait...who got me started down this rabbit hole...filled with nothing but fantasy and future disappointment?