Thanks, indeed The Stars goalie has been a point of contention during the Benn era (at least). However this season is a different from the previous ones.
One thing to note is their Dcorps is outstanding, if it was the year 2020. Other than Hammiius, they are young with limited NHL experience. After you add in Klimberg who’s primarily an offensive Dman . . .
The other thing, which also comes into play is the transition to Hitchcock’s system. It has only been 30-something games in the transition from their old firehouse style to Hitchcock’s heavier game. So despite being in the playoffision hunt, they have yet to prefect it.
Both of these result in The Stars goalies susceptible to facing a lot of shots that goalies on other teams necessarily wouldn’t , and ultimately needing to do more than most other goalies of playoff level teams. That being said, I give both of them a bit of a mulligan
Individually, as we’ve both seen them for years, they are both Jekyll and Hyde goalies. Some games either can be with the best in the world, other games they couldn’t stop a shot aimed at their chest. While this can be said for any goalie, it’s highly prevalent in both of them.
So while they are both quality NHL goalies, given the team situation and their tendencies, expecting either of them to be successful as “the number one goalie”, is very risky.
This year, they maybe best going the two headed monster/hot hand/best matchup route, like several teams with two starter quality goalies have done.
That being said, Bishop is a near ideal fit for Hitchcock’s system and the teams direction, but even more the teams system, direction, and huge Dcorps is likely ideal for Bishop. I’m pretty sure Nills plan is to have Bishop as the starter next year and going forward. . .
Great question though, I’ll reach out to my friends in Dallas later today and get his POV. He sits 3 rows behind the Stars goalie, so he’ll have some unique insight. (I’ll respond tonight after he’s gone through a half a bottle of Rye for some additional thoughts. . . as this sites uncensored I can share them here. . . :D )
